name: 62-marketing-review
description: "Dung khi leader phai DUYET output CHU cua team truoc khi trien khai — content brief co dung insight va dung pillar khong, CTA co ro khong; ads copy va creative co proof cho claim khong, dung tone khong, hook co nam trong 125 ky tu dau khong; verdict Approve / Revise / Redo kem feedback cu the. Kich hoat khi user nhac 'duyet brief', 'review ads copy', 'duyet content', 'check truoc khi chay', 'bai nay dang duoc chua', 'em viet the nay sep xem giup', 'duyet output team'. Khong dung cho — cham diem THIET KE va hinh anh thi dung skill 47-design-review; danh gia nang luc nguoi lam thi dung skill 65-team-performance-review; can nhieu goc nhin phan bien cho mot huong chien luoc thi dung skill 72-hoi-dong-marketing."
metadata:
version: 1.0.1
category: operations
license: MIT
triggers:
- "review brief content"
- "duyet brief"
- "review ads"
- "duyet ads"
- "duyet creative"
- "check ads truoc khi chay"
- "approve content"
- "review copy ads"
- "duyet output team"
output: "File .md — quick verdict, checklist review theo loai (content brief / ads), feedback cu the tung diem, verdict Approve / Minor revision / Redo + next step"
related:
- 36-content-brief
- 05-copy-quang-cao
- 47-design-review
- 02-brief-chien-dich
- 64-team-brief
Marketing Review — Duyet Output Team
Review brief truoc khi viet = sua 1 lan. Khong review = sua 5 lan sau khi viet xong. Review ads truoc khi launch = ngan lang phi budget vao creative sai; 1 gio review tiet kiem nhieu ngay CPL te. Leader review khong phai de "thich hay khong thich" — ma de dam bao dung objective, dung audience, dung brand. Visual/design → dung 47-design-review.
Thu thap thong tin
Hoi toi da 4 cau:
- Review cai gi? Content brief / ads copy + creative? Paste noi dung hoac share file.
- Campaign context: thuoc campaign nao, tang pheu nao (TOFU/MOFU/BOFU), platform nao?
- Audience target va KPI chinh cua campaign nay (CPL / ROAS / CTR)?
- Lan review thu may? Lan dau hay da qua revision — neu da 2 vong van sai, van de nam o brief goc, khong phai nguoi lam.
Nguyen tac
- Review theo checklist, khong theo cam giac. "Thich/khong thich" khong phai tieu chi.
- Feedback phai cu the va actionable. "Hook khong manh" khong du — phai noi "hook can hit pain [X] trong 3 giay dau / trong 125 ky tu dau".
- Review dung han: content brief trong 24h, ads trong 4-8h — khong de team cho.
- 1 revision toi da sau review. Neu van sai, Leader va nguoi lam ngoi lai cung nhau — khong ping-pong qua lai.
- Approve → launch trong 24h. Da duyet thi trien khai ngay, khong de tre mat momentum.
- Feedback ve system, khong ve con nguoi. Neu brief nhieu lan van nham, loi o brief — khong phai nguoi.
Quy trinh
Buoc 1 — Xac dinh loai review
| Loai output | Dung checklist | Ghi chu |
|---|
| Content brief (truoc khi writer viet) | Mode A ben duoi | |
| Ads copy + creative (truoc khi bat ads) | Mode B ben duoi | |
| Visual / design (banner, carousel, LP) | 47-design-review | Skill rieng cho visual |
Buoc 2 — Quick verdict (dien truoc, chi tiet sau)
| Hang muc | Danh gia | Ghi chu |
|---|
| Du thong tin de lam viec chua? | Du / Thieu | |
| Dung tang pheu chua? | OK / Warning / Fail | |
| Dung audience + insight chua? | OK / Warning / Fail | |
| Message nhat quan voi campaign? | OK / Warning / Fail | |
| Brand-safe (claim, legal, policy)? | OK / Fail | |
| Verdict | Approve / Can sua / Redo | |
Buoc 3A — Mode A: Checklist duyet content brief
Objective & tang pheu:
Audience & insight:
Angle & hook:
Message & CTA:
Format & proof:
Buoc 3B — Mode B: Checklist duyet ads (copy + creative)
Brand & legal (fail 1 muc = khong duyet):
Hook (quyet dinh 80% hieu qua):
Copy structure:
Funnel check:
Ky thuat:
Buoc 4 — Feedback cu the
Diem manh cua output nay: [ghi 1-2 diem — de nguoi lam biet giu gi]
| # | Van de | Tai sao can sua | Goi y sua the nao | Muc do |
|---|
| 1 | | | | Blocker / Nen sua |
| 2 | | | | |
Buoc 5 — Verdict + next step
| Verdict | Y nghia | Next step |
|---|
| APPROVE | Dat chuan | Writer viet ngay / Media buyer launch trong 24h |
| MINOR REVISION | Sua [X] diem cu the | Sua xong khong can duyet lai — tu launch |
| REDO / REBRIEF | Sai huong, can lam lai | Ghi ro ly do; neu la brief → viet lai brief; Leader + nguoi lam ngoi cung 15 phut |
Cau truc ket qua
Ten file: marketing-review-[ten-hang-muc]-[YYYYMMDD].md
# Review — [Content brief / Ads] — [Ten campaign]
Nguoi review: [Leader] | Ngay: [date] | Lan review: [1/2]
## 1. Quick verdict
| Hang muc | Danh gia | Ghi chu |
## 2. Checklist chi tiet
[Mode A hoac Mode B — tick tung muc, ghi chu muc fail]
## 3. Feedback
- Diem manh:
| # | Van de | Tai sao | Goi y sua | Muc do |
## 4. Verdict: APPROVE / MINOR REVISION / REDO
- Next step + deadline:
Lien ket skill
36-content-brief: brief content duoc tao tu skill nay la doi tuong review Mode A.
05-copy-quang-cao: ads copy duoc viet tu skill nay la doi tuong review Mode B.
47-design-review: visual/design co checklist rieng — khong duyet visual bang skill nay.
02-brief-chien-dich: campaign brief goc la chuan de doi chieu message nhat quan.
64-team-brief: khi REDO, dung team-brief de giao lai task voi definition of done ro hon.
Checklist chat luong