brainstorming
brainstorming
You MUST use this before any creative work - creating features, building components, adding functionality, modifying behavior, or planning anything new, in software or out of it (a talk, a business, a renovation).
minecraft-multiloaderBuild and maintain Architectury-based Minecraft 26.x or 1.21.x mods that share one codebase across NeoForge and Fabric. Use only when both loaders are required; use minecraft-modding for a single-loader project.
Independent GitHub snapshot · Automated classification · Original documentation governs
Architectury is a framework that
lets you write one mod codebase that compiles to both NeoForge and Fabric JARs.
The common subproject has a shared API; platform subprojects implement
platform-specific behavior behind the @ExpectPlatform abstraction.
Use when: one shared codebase must build and ship both NeoForge and Fabric artifacts.Do not use when: the project is single-loader only (minecraft-modding for NeoForge/Fabric, not both).Do not use when: the task is Paper/Bukkit plugin development (minecraft-plugin-dev).| Component | Purpose |
|---|---|
architectury-loom | Gradle plugin — extends Fabric Loom for multiloader support |
architectury-api | Runtime library — abstractions over both platforms |
@ExpectPlatform | Annotation marking methods with platform-specific implementations |
common/ | Shared code (no loader-specific APIs) |
fabric/ | Fabric-specific code + entrypoint |
neoforge/ | NeoForge-specific code + entrypoint |
# gradle.properties property names used by this skill's static helper.
# Get every tool version from the exact generated or known-working project.
mod_version=1.0.0
minecraft_version=1.21.11
enabled_platforms=fabric,neoforge
architectury_version=<project pin>
fabric_loader_version=<project pin>
fabric_api_version=<project pin ending in +1.21.11>
neoforge_version=<project pin in the 21.11.x family>
loom_version=<project pin>
Pin architectury_version, the Architectury plugin version, and loom_version
from the same generated or known-working project line. This skill deliberately
does not publish a copyable dependency matrix: its static helper cannot resolve
whether a particular set of versions is compatible.
For Minecraft 26.x / Java 25, use the official Architectury Template Generator only when its version selector offers the exact target. Generate a Multiplatform project with Fabric and NeoForge, then preserve the generated Gradle layout and pins as one set. If the generator does not offer the target, begin with an already working project on that exact line and inspect its resolved build; do not relabel a 1.21.11 template as 26.x. The published template downloads are not a substitute for an exact-current scaffold.
Do not mechanically change only minecraft_version in the retained example:
26.x is unobfuscated and its Loom/remapping setup differs from 1.21.11.
references/architectury-reference.md./scripts/check-version-sanity.sh --root <project>Run the sanity checker after editing gradle.properties. It is a static
syntax-and-version-family preflight: it catches missing keys, snapshot pins,
missing fabric / neoforge platforms, and obvious version-family drift. It
does not resolve dependencies, prove loader compatibility, or replace the
project's Fabric and NeoForge build and smoke tests.
my-mod/
├── build.gradle ← root build (shared config)
├── settings.gradle
├── gradle.properties
├── common/
│ ├── build.gradle
│ └── src/main/java/com/example/mymod/
│ ├── MyMod.java ← shared init
│ ├── registry/
│ │ └── ModItems.java ← shared registry declarations
│ └── platform/
│ └── PlatformHelper.java ← @ExpectPlatform methods
├── fabric/
│ ├── build.gradle
│ └── src/main/
│ ├── java/com/example/mymod/fabric/
│ │ ├── MyModFabric.java ← Fabric entrypoint
│ ├── java/com/example/mymod/platform/
│ │ └── PlatformHelperImpl.java ← Fabric @ExpectPlatform implementation
│ └── resources/
│ ├── fabric.mod.json
│ └── assets/...
└── neoforge/
├── build.gradle
└── src/main/
├── java/com/example/mymod/neoforge/
│ ├── MyModNeoForge.java ← NeoForge @Mod entry
├── java/com/example/mymod/platform/
│ └── PlatformHelperImpl.java ← NeoForge @ExpectPlatform implementation
└── resources/
├── META-INF/neoforge.mods.toml
└── assets/...
The old fixed Gradle scripts were a 1.21.11 snapshot and are intentionally not
presented as a current scaffold. For either supported version, read
references/legacy-1.21.11-template.md
or references/architectury-reference.md
before changing generated build files. They preserve version anchors and
source-set boundaries without encouraging a partial build script to be copied
into a different Minecraft line.
common/.../MyMod.javapackage com.example.mymod;
import dev.architectury.registry.registries.DeferredRegister;
import dev.architectury.registry.registries.RegistrySupplier;
import net.minecraft.core.registries.Registries;
import net.minecraft.resources.Identifier;
import net.minecraft.resources.ResourceKey;
import net.minecraft.world.item.Item;
public class MyMod {
public static final String MOD_ID = "mymod";
// Architectury's DeferredRegister — works on both platforms
public static final DeferredRegister<Item> ITEMS =
DeferredRegister.create(MOD_ID, Registries.ITEM);
public static final RegistrySupplier<Item> MY_ITEM =
ITEMS.register("my_item", () -> new Item(new Item.Properties().setId(
ResourceKey.create(Registries.ITEM,
Identifier.fromNamespaceAndPath(MOD_ID, "my_item"))
)));
public static void init() {
ITEMS.register(); // registers with both platforms
}
}
@ExpectPlatform — platform-specific methodsDefine the contract in common/:
package com.example.mymod.platform;
import dev.architectury.injectables.annotations.ExpectPlatform;
import net.minecraft.world.level.material.Fluid;
public class PlatformHelper {
@ExpectPlatform
public static boolean isModLoaded(String modId) {
// This body is replaced at compile time by the platform implementation
throw new AssertionError("ExpectPlatform implementation not found");
}
@ExpectPlatform
public static boolean isClient() {
throw new AssertionError();
}
}
Keep each platform implementation in the same Java package as the common
@ExpectPlatform class. Only the source set changes between common/,
fabric/, and neoforge/.
Implement in fabric/.../platform/PlatformHelperImpl.java:
package com.example.mymod.platform;
import net.fabricmc.loader.api.FabricLoader;
// Class name must match: <common class name>Impl
public class PlatformHelperImpl {
public static boolean isModLoaded(String modId) {
return FabricLoader.getInstance().isModLoaded(modId);
}
public static boolean isClient() {
return FabricLoader.getInstance().getEnvironmentType() ==
net.fabricmc.api.EnvType.CLIENT;
}
}
Implement in neoforge/.../platform/PlatformHelperImpl.java:
package com.example.mymod.platform;
import net.neoforged.fml.ModList;
import net.neoforged.fml.loading.FMLEnvironment;
public class PlatformHelperImpl {
public static boolean isModLoaded(String modId) {
return ModList.get().isLoaded(modId);
}
public static boolean isClient() {
return FMLEnvironment.dist.isClient();
}
}
fabric/.../MyModFabric.javapackage com.example.mymod.fabric;
import com.example.mymod.MyMod;
import net.fabricmc.api.ModInitializer;
public class MyModFabric implements ModInitializer {
@Override
public void onInitialize() {
MyMod.init();
}
}
fabric/.../resources/fabric.mod.jsonThis retained-1.21.11 metadata example follows the minimum dependencies in the upstream Architectury 1.21.11 branch. Keep the generated project's exact ranges when they are stricter.
{
"schemaVersion": 1,
"id": "mymod",
"version": "${version}",
"name": "My Mod",
"description": "A multiloader example mod",
"license": "MIT",
"environment": "*",
"entrypoints": {
"main": ["com.example.mymod.fabric.MyModFabric"]
},
"depends": {
"fabricloader": ">=0.18.2",
"fabric-api": ">=0.139.4+1.21.11",
"architectury": ">=19.0",
"minecraft": "~1.21.11"
}
}
neoforge/.../MyModNeoForge.javapackage com.example.mymod.neoforge;
import com.example.mymod.MyMod;
import net.neoforged.bus.api.IEventBus;
import net.neoforged.fml.common.Mod;
@Mod(MyMod.MOD_ID)
public class MyModNeoForge {
public MyModNeoForge(IEventBus modEventBus) {
MyMod.init();
}
}
neoforge/.../resources/META-INF/neoforge.mods.tomlmodLoader = "javafml"
loaderVersion = "[1,)"
license = "MIT"
[[mods]]
modId = "mymod"
version = "${file.jarVersion}"
displayName = "My Mod"
description = "A multiloader example mod"
[[dependencies.mymod]]
modId = "neoforge"
type = "required"
versionRange = "[21.11,)"
ordering = "NONE"
side = "BOTH"
[[dependencies.mymod]]
modId = "minecraft"
type = "required"
versionRange = "[1.21.11,1.22)"
ordering = "NONE"
side = "BOTH"
# Build both JARs simultaneously
./gradlew build
# Inspect the project's actual outputs. Generated templates choose their own
# archive base name and version convention:
find fabric/build/libs neoforge/build/libs -maxdepth 1 -type f -name '*.jar' \
! -name '*-sources.jar' ! -name '*-dev.jar' ! -name '*-javadoc.jar'
# Run in dev environment
./gradlew :fabric:runClient
./gradlew :neoforge:runClient
./gradlew :neoforge:runServer
# Datagen (if applicable)
./gradlew :neoforge:runData
| Pitfall | Solution |
|---|---|
Using net.neoforged.* / net.fabricmc.* in common/ | Only use vanilla MC and Architectury APIs in common |
Direct field access on DeferredRegister (NeoForge style) in common | Use Architectury's DeferredRegister |
| Constructing a 26.x item without a registry key | Create its ResourceKey<Item> and call Item.Properties#setId before new Item |
Forgetting @ExpectPlatform throws AssertionError at runtime | Both fabric/ and neoforge/ must have matching same-package *Impl classes |
| Assets duplicated in fabric/ and neoforge/ | Keep assets in common/src/main/resources/assets/ |
| A common Mixin imports a loader API or targets one loader's side | Put it in that platform subproject; loader-neutral Mixins may be common when both generated platform configurations include them |
| Accessing world/registry on mod init thread | Use mod bus events for setup; never access world on init |